BidRush.aiCalculate profit ↗
Home/Guides/COMPARISON
COMPARISON · ONE ITEM, EIGHT FEE MODELS

The same $60 item on eight marketplaces.

“Which marketplace has the lowest fees?” is a useful question with a misleading answer. The lowest fee on paper may be the platform with the slowest sell-through, the highest return rate or the smallest audience for your category. A fee table is a starting point, not a ranking.

This guide holds the item and costs constant and applies each marketplace’s representative US fee model to a $60 sale. The item costs $18, the seller pays $6.50 for the label and packaging, and the buyer pays no shipping. The exercise shows how much of the variation comes from the fee model and how much comes from assumptions that differ between platforms. Then it adds back the factors a spreadsheet cannot capture.

The ground rules

Every row uses the same sale price, item cost and seller-paid postage. The fee is the sum of the modeled marketplace commission, payment processing, listing fee and fixed fees. Promotion is zero. Taxes collected and remitted by the marketplace are excluded from revenue and from the fee base. The seller’s profit is sale price minus modeled fees, item cost and postage. No platform-specific shipping subsidy, return or storage cost is included; those are discussed separately.

The comparison is not perfectly apples-to-apples because the platforms do not sell the same way. Poshmark’s buyer pays a shipping label; Mercari’s fee base includes buyer-paid shipping; Vinted’s buyer pays a protection fee; StockX and GOAT involve authentication and seller shipping to the platform. Holding buyer-paid shipping at zero is a simplifying assumption. It makes the fee models comparable, not the total customer experience.

$60 sale, $18 item cost, $6.50 seller postage, no buyer-paid shipping, no promotion
MarketplaceModeled feeEffective fee rateProfit after costsProfit margin
Vinted$0.000.0%$35.5059.2%
Depop$2.434.1%$33.0755.1%
PayPal G&S (no marketplace)$2.584.3%$32.9254.9%
Mercari$6.0010.0%$29.5049.2%
Facebook Marketplace$6.0010.0%$29.5049.2%
Etsy$6.1510.3%$29.3548.9%
Whatnot$6.8411.4%$28.6647.8%
StockX$7.2012.0%$28.3047.2%
eBay$8.5614.3%$26.9444.9%
Amazon FBM$9.0015.0%$26.5044.2%
GOAT$10.7017.8%$24.8041.3%
Poshmark$12.0020.0%$23.5039.2%

What the table actually says

The spread is $12.00 of profit between the highest and lowest fee, on a $60 sale. That is 20% of the sale price, which is large enough to matter. But the ordering is not a quality ranking. Vinted has no seller fee in this model, yet it may not be the right marketplace for a $60 item that needs authentication, detailed condition grading or a broad audience. Poshmark has the highest fee in the table, yet it may be the best place to sell a $60 dress because its buyers expect fashion pricing and its shipping label simplifies the transaction.

The effective fee rate is a better comparison than the headline commission because it includes fixed and processing fees. eBay’s headline 13.6% becomes 14.3% after the $0.40 order fee. Etsy’s headline 6.5% becomes 10.3% after payment processing and the listing fee. Poshmark’s 20% is exactly 20% because there is no separate processing fee on the item price. These differences are structural, not promotional.

The PayPal row is included as a reference point, not as a marketplace. PayPal’s 3.49% + $0.49 is a payment-processing fee, not a selling fee. If you sell through your own website, you still pay for hosting, traffic, customer service and returns; those costs are not in the table. A low payment fee is not a low total cost of selling.

Fixed fees matter less at $60, but they still matter

At $60, the fixed fees are a small share of the transaction. eBay’s $0.40 is 0.7% of the sale; Etsy’s $0.45 is 0.75%; Poshmark’s 20% has no fixed component. The ranking would change at lower prices. At $8, eBay’s fixed order fee and Etsy’s processing and listing fees would be a much larger share, while Poshmark’s $2.95 flat fee would be punishing. A comparison table is price-specific; do not assume the same order holds for a $10 item.

The same fee models at $12 and $120, for context
MarketplaceFee at $12Effective rateFee at $120Effective rate
eBay$2.0316.9%$16.7213.9%
Etsy$1.4412.0%$11.859.9%
Poshmark$2.95 (flat)24.6%$24.0020.0%
Mercari$1.2010.0%$12.0010.0%
Depop$0.857.1%$4.413.7%
Vinted$0.000.0%$0.000.0%

At $12, Poshmark’s flat fee is the highest effective rate in the group, even though its 20% rate at $60 is also the highest. eBay and Etsy are more expensive at $12 than at $120 because their fixed fees are spread over fewer dollars. Vinted stays at zero because there is no seller fee in the model, but the buyer-facing protection fee may be a larger share of a cheap item, which can affect conversion.

What the table leaves out

The biggest omission is demand. A marketplace with a 5% fee and no buyers is more expensive than a marketplace with a 20% fee and a buyer waiting. Sell-through rate, search placement, category focus and audience size determine how quickly an item turns into cash. A $23.50 profit that arrives in two weeks can be better than a $35.50 profit that arrives in six months, especially if the capital is needed for the next sourcing trip.

The second omission is shipping. Poshmark’s buyer-paid label, Mercari’s label options, eBay’s calculated shipping and Vinted’s prepaid labels all produce different buyer experiences and different seller costs when the parcel is heavier than expected. The table assumes the seller pays $6.50 on every platform. In reality, a platform-negotiated label may be cheaper or more expensive than your own carrier rate for the same parcel. That difference can exceed the fee difference between two platforms.

The third omission is returns. Fashion marketplaces have higher return rates than collectibles or electronics. A 20% return rate on a 20% fee platform can be more expensive than a 10% return rate on a 14% fee platform. The return cost includes the outbound label, the return label, the lost time and the risk that the item comes back in worse condition. Add an expected return cost per unit before comparing platforms on fee alone.

  • Authentication and grading: StockX and GOAT add process and cost, but may command higher prices.
  • Audience and sell-through: a specialist platform can sell faster even at a higher fee.
  • Shipping label pricing: platform rates versus your own carrier account.
  • Return rates and policies: who pays the return label, and how often returns happen.
  • Payout timing: when the money arrives and whether that matters for cash flow.
  • Promotion costs: percentage-of-sale ads or pay-per-click budgets.
  • Customer service and dispute handling: time is a cost.
  • Tax reporting and sales tax collection: administrative burden varies.

A category-specific view

For a $60 used dress, Poshmark, Mercari, Depop and Vinted are plausible venues. Poshmark’s 20% is high, but its buyer base expects fashion and its prepaid label removes friction. Depop’s 3.3% + $0.45 is much cheaper, but the audience skews younger and more trend-driven; a classic dress may sit. Vinted has no seller fee, but the buyer pays protection and shipping, which can make the total look expensive for a $60 item. Mercari’s 10% is a middle ground with a broad audience.

For a $60 vintage camera, eBay and Mercari are more natural. eBay’s 14.3% effective fee buys a large audience of collectors and completed-sale data; Mercari’s 10% may be cheaper but has a smaller collector base. Facebook Marketplace’s 10% applies to shipped orders and can work for local or social selling, but the buyer protection and shipping experience differ. Vinted is a poor fit for a camera; the audience is there for fashion, not electronics.

For a $60 pair of sneakers, StockX and GOAT add authentication and a specialized buyer base. The fee is higher than eBay’s in this example, but the buyer may pay a premium for authentication. eBay has a large sneaker market and a lower fee, but the seller handles more of the authentication and dispute risk. The right choice depends on the item’s provenance, condition and the price premium the specialist venue commands.

A decision framework

Start with the venue where the item has the best chance of selling at a good price. Then calculate the fee and the profit on that venue using the actual shipping and cost assumptions. Compare it with one alternative venue, not with all twelve. If the profit difference is small relative to the difference in sell-through, choose the faster venue. If the profit difference is large and the item is in demand on both, choose the higher-profit venue.

Do not optimize for the lowest fee in isolation. A 0% fee on a platform where the item does not sell is a 0% return on your inventory cost. A 20% fee on a platform where it sells in a week may be the best business decision you make that month. The table tells you what each platform takes; the market tells you what each platform gives. You need both numbers.

Finally, revisit the comparison when fees change, when your shipping costs change, or when your inventory mix shifts. A table built for a $60 fashion item does not answer a question about a $12 book or a $300 electronics item. The arithmetic is the same, but the ranking is not. Use the calculator for the item in front of you, and use this comparison to understand why the numbers move.

PUT THE MATH TO WORKCompare with your own numbers
Open the calculator →

Frequently asked questions

Which marketplace has the lowest fees?

In this $60 example, Vinted has no seller fee, followed by Depop and PayPal. But the lowest fee is not the same as the highest profit or the fastest sale. Poshmark and GOAT have higher fees but may reach buyers who will pay more for the item.

Why is Etsy’s effective fee higher than 6.5%?

Because Etsy also charges payment processing (3% + $0.25 in the US) and a $0.20 listing fee. On a $60 sale, those add about $2.25, bringing the total to roughly 10.3% of the sale before advertising.

Does this comparison include shipping and returns?

It includes a fixed $6.50 seller-paid postage assumption on every row. It does not include platform-specific label prices, shipping subsidies, return rates or return labels. Those can change the ranking, especially for heavy or return-prone items.

Should I list on every marketplace?

Not necessarily. Cross-listing can increase exposure but also creates duplicate inventory, different fee models and more customer-service work. Start with the venue that fits the item and the buyer, then add a second venue only if the incremental sales justify the extra work.

Official sources

Fee schedules change. The rates in this guide are the ones recorded in the BidRush dataset on the date shown, with the linked official page as the primary source. Confirm the amount in your seller account before pricing.

BidRush is independent and not affiliated with any marketplace. This guide is general information, not financial, legal or tax advice.