How to calculate your minimum selling price.
Most pricing advice starts with the market: look at sold comps, find the range, pick a number. That is necessary, but it is only half the decision. The other half is your floor: the lowest price at which a sale still pays you for the item, the postage and the work. A price can be competitive and still lose money. A floor tells you when to walk away.
The floor is not a single number for all platforms. Each marketplace has a different variable rate, fixed fee and shipping rule. This guide gives you one formula that covers all of them, works through eBay, Etsy, Poshmark, Mercari and Vinted, and shows how to add a target profit rather than merely breaking even.
The four inputs
Every marketplace pricing problem reduces to four inputs. First, your item cost: what you paid, including any sourcing travel allocated per item. Second, your shipping and packaging cost: the label, mailer, tape and protective materials you actually pay for. Third, the marketplace’s fee structure: a variable percentage plus any fixed fee. Fourth, the shipping you charge the buyer, which adds to revenue and usually to the fee base.
A fifth input is your target profit. Break-even is the price where profit is zero. A business cannot run at zero, so the useful floor includes a target. That target can be a dollar amount per item or a required return on cost. Both are valid; the dollar target is easier to use when you are pricing one item, and the return target is better when you are allocating capital across many items.
| Input | Symbol | Example value |
|---|---|---|
| Item cost | c | $12.00 |
| Postage + packaging | p | $6.00 |
| Variable fee rate | v | 13.6% (eBay) |
| Fixed fee | f | $0.40 (eBay) |
| Buyer-paid shipping | s | $0.00 |
| Target profit | t | $10.00 |
The formula
Let P be the item price. The buyer pays P + s. The marketplace takes v × (P + s) + f. Your profit is (P + s) − v(P + s) − f − c − p. Simplify: (P + s)(1 − v) − f − c − p. Set that equal to your target t and solve for P.
The formula works because the variable fee is a share of every additional dollar, while the fixed fee and your costs are absolute. Dividing by (1 − v) “grosses up” the costs to account for the share the marketplace takes. If v is 13.6%, every dollar of required net costs about $1.157 of price. That is the entire trick.
Worked example: eBay
With a $12 item cost, $6 postage and packaging, a $0.40 order fee and a 13.6% variable rate, the break-even price is ($12 + $6 + $0.40) ÷ 0.864 = $21.30 if the buyer pays no shipping. To earn $10, add the target to the numerator: ($12 + $6 + $0.40 + $10) ÷ 0.864 = $32.87. At $32.87, the fee is $4.47, the payout is $28.40, and after $18 of costs the profit is $10.00.
If you charge the buyer $5 shipping, the item price floor falls by $5 to $27.87, because the shipping revenue contributes $5 and the fee on it is already accounted for in the formula. The buyer’s total is still $32.87. This is why “free shipping” and “separate shipping” can be economically equivalent at the same total: the fee base and the revenue are the same. The difference is conversion and search presentation, not the underlying math.
| Target profit | Minimum item price | Fee at that price | Profit check |
|---|---|---|---|
| $0 (break-even) | $21.30 | $3.30 | $0.00 |
| $5 | $27.08 | $4.08 | $5.00 |
| $10 | $32.87 | $4.87 | $10.00 |
| $20 | $44.44 | $6.44 | $20.00 |
The same floor across marketplaces
Using the same $12 item cost, $6 postage and $10 target, the floor changes with the fee model. The table below uses each platform’s representative US rate and no buyer-paid shipping. Poshmark uses the 20% regime because the resulting price is above $15. Depop uses 3.3% + $0.45 and no selling commission. Vinted has no seller fee. These are planning estimates, not quotes.
| Marketplace | Fee model used | Minimum price | Fee at that price | Profit check |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vinted | 0% seller fee | $28.00 | $0.00 | $10.00 |
| Depop | 3.3% + $0.45 | $29.42 | $1.42 | $10.00 |
| Mercari | 10% | $31.11 | $3.11 | $10.00 |
| Etsy US | 6.5% + 3% + $0.45 fixed | $31.44 | $3.44 | $10.00 |
| Whatnot | 8% + 2.9% + $0.30 | $31.76 | $3.76 | $10.00 |
| eBay | 13.6% + $0.40 | $32.87 | $4.87 | $10.00 |
| Amazon FBM | 15%, $0.30 minimum | $32.94 | $4.94 | $10.00 |
| Poshmark | 20% at $15+ | $35.00 | $7.00 | $10.00 |
The spread is $7.00 between Vinted and Poshmark on the same item. That does not mean Vinted is always better. The platforms have different audiences, sell-through rates, return behavior and shipping expectations. A $28 price on Vinted with a 20% chance of selling in 30 days is not automatically better than a $35 price on Poshmark with a 60% chance. Use the floor to compare like with like, then adjust for demand.
The fixed-fee trap
Fixed fees break the smooth percentage intuition. Poshmark is the clearest example: below $15 the fee is $2.95, and at $15 or above it is 20%. Suppose your item cost is $5, postage is $4.50 and your target is $4. Under the flat-fee regime, the required price is $5 + $4.50 + $2.95 + $4 = $16.45. But $16.45 is above $15, so the 20% regime applies, and the required price becomes ($5 + $4.50 + $4) ÷ 0.8 = $16.88. The answer is $16.88, not $16.45, because the first answer invalidated its own assumption.
The same trap appears on eBay at the $10 order-fee boundary and on Etsy because of the $0.25 processing and $0.20 listing fees. Always check whether the computed price falls on the side of the threshold you assumed. If it does not, recompute with the other regime. A spreadsheet formula that ignores the boundary can be wrong by a few percent, which is enough to erase a thin margin.
Target profit vs. target margin
A dollar target is easy to understand: “I want $10 on this item.” A margin target is a percentage of revenue: “I want 30%.” The two produce different prices. At a $32.87 price, $10 of profit is a 30.4% margin. If you want a 40% margin instead, the formula changes: P = (c + p + f) ÷ (1 − v − m) − s, where m is the margin. With m = 0.40, the denominator is 1 − 0.136 − 0.40 = 0.464, and the price is ($18.40) ÷ 0.464 = $39.66. That is a much higher floor.
Margin targets are useful for comparing products of different prices, but they can push you above the market on inexpensive items. A $5 profit on a $20 sale is a 25% margin and may be excellent; a $5 profit on a $100 sale is a 5% margin and may be too thin for the capital tied up. Choose the target that matches your business: dollars per hour for a side hustle, return on capital for inventory, or margin for a brand.
Rounding, psychology and the actual listing price
The floor is a constraint, not a recommended price. Once you know the floor, look at sold comps and choose a price above it that the market will bear. Round to a sensible number, but round up, not down. If the floor is $32.87, listing at $32.99 preserves the target; listing at $32.00 gives away 87 cents of profit for no strategic reason. Charm pricing at $32.99 or $33.00 is fine; $29.99 is below the floor.
Leave room for offers. If buyers routinely negotiate 10%, a $36.99 list price with a $33 floor gives you room to accept a modest offer and still hit the target. A $33 list price with the same floor forces you to decline every offer, which can hurt sell-through. The floor tells you the walk-away point; the list price is a negotiation opening.
When to walk away
If the market price is below your floor, you have four options: lower your cost, lower your postage, change the platform, or do not sell the item. Lowering cost means sourcing better or buying in larger lots. Lowering postage means lighter packaging or a different carrier. Changing the platform means accepting a different fee model and audience. Not selling is a legitimate choice; a negative-margin sale consumes cash and time that could go to a better item.
Review the floor when fees change, when your carrier changes its rates, or when you change your packaging. A floor computed with last year’s postage is a guess. Recompute it for your top-selling categories and keep it next to the listing template. The sellers who last are not the ones with the cleverest pricing trick; they are the ones who know their numbers and refuse to sell below them.
Frequently asked questions
What is the formula for a minimum selling price?
For a percentage-plus-fixed fee, P = (item cost + postage + fixed fee + target profit) ÷ (1 − variable rate) − buyer-paid shipping. If the fee is charged only on the item price, do not subtract the shipping term. For flat-fee or tiered platforms, check which regime the answer falls into and recompute if needed.
Should I include my time in the minimum price?
Ideally yes. Estimate the minutes spent sourcing, photographing, listing, packing and shipping, multiply by an hourly rate you would accept, and add it as a cost. Many sellers omit time at the start; as volume grows, it becomes the largest hidden cost.
Is break-even the same as minimum price?
Break-even is the price where profit is zero. A useful minimum price includes a target profit, because a business that only breaks even cannot absorb returns, mistakes or slow months. Use break-even as an absolute floor and the target price as your normal listing floor.
Why is the Poshmark floor higher than the others?
Poshmark’s standard commission is 20% above $15, the highest representative rate in this comparison. It also has a flat $2.95 fee below $15, which can be worse for very cheap items. The floor reflects the fee model, not a judgment about the platform.
Official sources
- eBay — Selling fees (official) ↗
- Etsy — Fees & Payments policy (official) ↗
- Poshmark — Seller fees (official support) ↗
- Mercari — Selling fees (official help) ↗
Fee schedules change. The rates in this guide are the ones recorded in the BidRush dataset on the date shown, with the linked official page as the primary source. Confirm the amount in your seller account before pricing.
BidRush is independent and not affiliated with any marketplace. This guide is general information, not financial, legal or tax advice.